Bushcraft vs LNT
Description
http://paulkirtley.co.uk
This is a section of #AskPaulKirtley which many people particularly liked. Some viewers suggested that I release it as a separate video. So, here it is...
And here is the link to the full episode of #askpaulkirtley - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PA5cXwn65a0
LET'S CONNECT:
You can also connect with me on social media:
Instagram: https://instagram.com/paulkirtley/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/PaulKirtleysBlog
Twitter: https://twitter.com/pkirt
GET MORE WILDERNESS SKILLS ADVICE & INFO:
http://paulkirtley.co.uk/free-tips-and-advice/
Tags: bushcraft,LNT,leave no trace,environment,camping,hiking,fires,campfires,traditional skills,modern camping,lightweight camping,bushcraft vs LNT,LNT vs bushcraft,Paul Kirtley,Paul Kirtley Bushcraft,paulkirtley,conservation,environmentalism,environmental protection,keeping things in perspective
Video Transcription
next one is about Leave No Trace and bushcraft and this is from Rob Hayden and his question is hella Paul I always enjoy your work and value your opinions I'm from the US but hope to travel to England one day and participate in one of your courses that would be good Rob maybe I can come and do a workshop in the States one of these years as well as possibility we'll see I'd like your opinion on a statement that was posted on an internet forum hopefully I'm not jumping into jumping into a pool with sharks here and jumping in at the deep end but anyway bushcraft and Leave No Trace is at cross-purposes leave no traces and outdoor philosophy whereby one minimizes his or her impact on the natural world while traveling or camping in the backcountry on the other hand bushcraft uses skills such as fire lighting and shelter building where the emphasis is on the use of materials from the natural world to practice and refine those skills by its very nature bushcraft alters the natural world in some small or not so small way to be fair the original statement about leaving a trace and brush grappling across purposes was posted on a forum discussing the Appalachian Trail which sees intensive use by millions of hikers every season in that context I totally agree that all hikers should practice Leave No Trace principles if not the Appalachian Trail corridor would quickly become denuded of any vegetation and cluttered with a litter of modern society but what about areas of less intensive use does a gathering of dead wood for a campfire or the building of a shelter from natural materials really matter in the long run what is the responsible thing to do given these two opposing goals I very much like to hear your opinion thank you rob quite a long question Rob but worth while and worth having a discussion about I've had discussions of a similar nature with people online people certainly have come onto my blog and looked at say for example some of the fire lighting aspects and said that it's irresponsible they've said similar things about to building and personally I think it's irresponsible for me not to share those pieces of knowledge with people if they can help save somebody's life we you mentioned the Appalachian Trail we've had a few unfortunate cases in recent years of individuals who have been quite well equipped either through hiking or day hiking or doing a multi-day section of the Appalachian Trail and in fact other long-distance trails in other parts of North America and unfortunately perishing and at the end of the day it's the lack of skills and lack of experience in nature and that's not meant in an airy-fairy way it's just lack of skills lack of experience which unfortunately was certainly contributing factor to some of those people you can have all the kit in the world but if you don't have some basic knowledge of hypothermia of heat loss to an environment of signaling of relocation strategies in terms of your navigation skills and in terms of carrying the correct navigation equipment in terms of understanding what people do when you're missing in terms of how do they search for you where do they search and having a good strategy in place in terms of leaving word and somebody doing something about you not coming back all of those things need to be in place you need to have some basic skills the ability to light a fire the ability to find water the ability to navigate wet by natural means the ability to find food they're not necessarily something that you're going to use very much at all on a long distance hike such as on the Appalachian Trail but if you come and stuck they're useful back stops and so I would say they're worth knowing for those reasons but that wasn't the core of your question the core of your question was about Leave No Trace versus bushcraft and and the ethos of Leave No Trace and on the one hand i think is a very good one because it's about minimizing your impact on an environment that your visit thing and I think that's a good message and I think that's a good philosophy and i would say anyone who considers themselves a bushcraft person or a bushcraft that should also look to minimize the impact that they have whatever they're doing the impact of that activity on the environment because you can have a fire and make a right bloody mess or have a fire and leave very very little trace to the extent where nobody would notice other than somebody who's got some tracking skills and so it's about it's about degrees nobody that visits an environment is going to leave no trace whatsoever unless they can levitate they're going to have an impact on an environment and just by walking through it they will have an environment by their football by urinating by defecating by camping in particular spots they will have an impact on the environment so you cannot hike and camp in an area without having an impact on it it's just a matter of degree many bushcraft skills and you mentioned shelter building and fire lighting they will have an impact on the environment and they will use natural resources at the end of the day I always say bushcraft is about study of nature and a study of the use of natural resources but equally we need to balance that with some consideration and for nature we also need to cut balance it with some consideration for other users and we don't want to be leaving fire scars we don't want to be stripping birch bark from live trees in any circumstances really and you know I see people doing that and that gives bushcraft a bad name you should be looking to minimize the impact and I don't think people should be building big natural shelters or on trails like the Appalachian Trail because it's at odds with what you're trying to achieve you need to be covering a distance and I've not hiked the Appalachian Trail personally I've had some very close friends who have and to thru hike the Appalachian Trail in one season takes you all your time to be walking and moving on most days you're not going to be building natural shelters and and so that's not even an option the this so i would i would admit that building shelters lighting fires does consume some local materials in an area and the question then is do you want to be doing that is it so is it so intensely used that that is going to be of a detriment to the area where i am at the moment I've been coming here for 35 years in this area in the north of England and very very few people come here if I was to camp here and have a fire and leave very very little trace of my of my presence here I'm sat on a huge piece of dead oak if i was to burn us if i was to have a campfire here tonight I'd burn a small about very very small amount of it I do it there's a small stream I would maybe do it on the banks of the stream where it's going to get washed away in high water and on ground that's safe and I wouldn't be doing it over there underneath some coniferous trees which are over there where I might set fire to the root systems consideration for the environment and leaving very very little trace I'm gonna have very little impact on this area and some people would say the Leave No Trace and zealots and there are some zealots out there they would say you can't do that you should not have that you should not be doing that well what I'll throw back at those people are if you are hiking through an area with your plastic gear your metal stoves where do those resources come from where does the oil come from to make the plastic things that you're using people talk about having putting down a sheet to have a mound fire where does that plastic come from where does it go when you finished using it at the end of its life the end of your life metal stoves yet they have less impact on the environment than having a fire the local environment but where does a metal come from what about the big hole in the ground where the the minerals were dug out what about the row to that mine what about the processing plant and the the pollution from the steel mill or the aluminium mill and the plans you know extraction of bauxite turning of bauxite into aluminium is very energy intensive and aluminium plants are often near hydroelectric schemes because they need that much electricity what's the impact of flooding an area for a hydro scheme to generate electricity to then and the impact of an aluminium plant and the extraction of bauxite so that you can have your aluminium parts of your stove so that you don't have a fire in the local environment every single thing that we consume has an effect somewhere on the planet and so at the end of the day I think it's an argument about local impact versus a wider impact and in your question you talked about having a smaller a large impact I don't think any bushcraft activity has a large impact in terms of what you can do as an individual on a local environment unless you accidentally start a bushfire and that isn't a bushcraft activity that's just that's just carelessness it's an accident you could do that with a stove you could do that with a petrol stove as well and so you need to be careful whenever you've got any sort of flame in an environment that is prone to being ignited you need to follow the rules and you need to be careful but that aside I think it's an argument about local impact versus global impact the biggest impacts on our environment are not people going camping the biggest impact on our environment our people driving to the trailhead in cars that burn fuel that are made of steel and aluminium and plastic and even if you use an electric car where does the where do the wet is there nickel and lithium and all the other ingredients for batteries where does that come from where's the hole in the ground that that comes out of where does that go when it's finished and every single thing that you do has an impact using em gore-tex or other breathable fabrics they're made of plastic it's made of oil using a metal stove it comes out the ground burning fuels and you know even white gas Coleman fuel you're very clean but it's made it's a petrochemical it comes out the ground somewhere and so we're arguing about people having campfires versus using stoves and some instances yet we're burning fuel in our cars and in our homes when we're not in the wilderness that is based on people deforesting areas of Alberta and extracting oil from tar sands we're using wood in our homes in chipboard for furniture and other aspects of our homes that that is doubt that is being used and there's been taken from clear cutting and clear felling them you know there is a lot that we there's a massive impact that we have particularly in the first world because most people who go on wilderness trips are wealthy enough to have the time where they can go and do those things where the biggest consumers in our day-to-day life so I think it's completely absurd frankly that we're arguing about these small differences in a local environment when we're having such big big impacts in our home lives and those are the areas where we should really be focusing on and now I going back to the original question should some areas not not have fires and camping and have very tight restrictions absolutely national parks provincial parks areas that are popular that get a lot of people going to them they need to be protected both for the sake of the natural environment and for the sake of the enjoyment of other people who are going there so yes and we do need to strike a balance but I don't think bushcraft is inherently bad and I don't think Leave No Trace is inherently bad i think the philosophies sometimes and our odds for reasons which are ludicrous and there are reasons for applying each in different circumstances and i think even if you're doing something like hiking the Appalachian Trail you should have a backstop of bushcraft and survival skills because then if you do get lost if you do get into trouble then you've got a fallback set of skills that you can fall back on and do remember if you're carrying plastic metal and things yes you'll have less impact on that local environment but you're having a big impact somewhere else because you're part of that industrial use of nature and which has far bigger consequences look at the Amazon look at em oil tar sands look at em oil drilling around the world look at metals mining look at industrial plants for smelting and turning materials into metals look at oil refineries that is what you're using when you're relying entirely on kit in the wilderness you're having an effect somewhere else and it may be out site it may be out of mind but you're still having an impact on the planet that's my view you
About the Author
Paul Kirtley
Bushcraft, survival skills and outdoor safety with professional instructor Paul Kirtley.
More articles from this author
- Bushcraft Courses Behind The Scenes - Easter Weekend Snapchat Feed
- Bushcraft: How To Tie A Taut Tarp Hitch
- Axe Techniques: Firewood Splitting On Snow
- How To Poop In The Woods
- How To Pack A Week's Food Into A PLCE Side Pocket
- Improvised Coffee Percolator
- #AskPaulKirtley Episode 2 - Bivvy Bags, Tarps, Titanium Pots, Watches & Wardrobes...
- Lightweight Tarp And Bivvy Set Up
- Fire Dragon Fuel Gel From BCB - Initial Thoughts
- Water Filters, Pignut Recipes, Emergency Communications | #AskPaulKirtley 49
- Beginning Bushcraft - Which Knife To Choose?
- Survival Tins, Space Blankets, Canvas vs Synthetic, Dealing With Fear | #AskPaulKirtley Ep. 27
- Bow Drill Woods To Avoid, Beech Nut Edibility, Teeth and Nails | #AskPaulKirtley 36
- How To Tie The Simplest (But Also Most Useful) Knot In The World
- Fire Safety, Winter Evenings, Billy Cans vs Other Stainless Pots | #AskPaulKirtley 50
- First Run In The Prospector This Season
- #AskPaulKirtley Ep. 18 - Power In The Wild, Water Purification, Chaga & What I Have In My Pockets
- Exploding Rocks, Carving Utensils, Dangerous Gases, Worn Firesteels | #AskPaulKirtley Ep. 25
- #AskPaulKirtley Episode 4 - Biting Insects, Wild Foods, Tree ID and Water Purification
- Ice Bucket Challenge - Paul Kirtley
- #AskPaulKirtley Episode 53 - LIVE at the Bushcaft Show 2017
- Fire Watch Sleep Rotation, Tarp Set-ups, Kit Weight & Load-outs | #AskPaulKirtley 56
- Integrating Bushcraft With Modern Outdoor Life | Bushcraft Show 2014
- #AskPaulKirtley Ep. 20 - Ember Extenders, Natural Soaps, Safe Wild Edibles, Tapping For Sap...
- How To Hank Cordage For Bushcraft, Survival & Outdoor Life
- Water Purification, Water Sterilisation, Water Contaminants | #AskPaulKirtley 39
- Fun Slides, Rock Steps And Surfing On The Tees
- #AskPaulKirtley Episode 5 - Knife Sharpening, Knives & The Law, Bears In Sweden And More...
- Winter Camping: What To Look For In A Snow Shovel
- #AskPaulKirtley Ep. 19 - Top 3 Bushcraft Areas, Natural Cordage Bow Drill, Beginner & Budget Axes
- #AskPaulKirtley Ep. 7 - Roadkill, Advice to Aspiring Instructors, A Herb Brainstorm and Snails!
- Winter Bushcraft & Survival: Generating Water From Snow
- #AskPaulKirtley Ep. 9 - Knife Techniques, Wool Blankets vs Hammocks, First Aid & Primitive Skills
- Bushcraft Instructing, Winter Wild Edibles, Uses Of Willow | #AskPaulKirtley 48
- #AskPaulKirtley Ep. 8 - Thoughts On Preppers, Frustrated Kids & Some Book Recommendations
- Carbon Steel Knives & Flint, 3-Season Bag Choice, Knowing Enough For Wilderness | #AskPaulKirtley 38
- Hygiene In The Bush: How To Stay Clean
- Winter Tinder, Meat Today vs Past, Australian Plant ID, Cameras & Tripods | #AskPaulKirtley Ep. 22
- Does Boiling Always Make Water Safe To Drink?
- Toxic Pines, Fire Plough, Navigating At Night, Paramo Clothing | #AskPaulKirtley 57
- Fighting The Tide On The Menai Strait
- Wash Day
- Bushcraft Quick Tips - How To Cut A Stick With Only A Pocket Knife
- Choosing An Axe For Winter Camping And Travel
- #AskPaulKirtley Ep. 16 - eVent Jackets, Surplus Gear For Bushcraft, Carbs, Fire and Religion
- #AskPaulKirtley Ep. 21 - Wild Camps, Canoeing, Knife Skills, Firesteel Quality & Drinking Urine
- Tryweryn River Canoeing - Ray Goodwin's Eddy Challenge
- How To Pack Your Bushcraft Camping Gear Into A Rucksack
- The Value Of Using Wilderness Skills Closer To Home | Bushcraft Show 2016
- White Water Safety And Rescue Training With Ray Goodwin
- Bear-Resistant Containers, Modern SAKs, Skis, Bushcraft and Trash | #AskPaulKirtley 34
- #AskPaulKirtley Ep. 13 - Boots, EDC Kit, Bow-Drill Positions, Bushcraft During Hunting Season
- Tees Training Day
- 21 Winter Woodland Wildcamping Tips For Bushcrafters
- Tinders For Flint & Steel, Long Term Winter Shelters, Wild Camping In The UK | #AskPaulKirtley 46
- Bushcraft Knife Sharpening: Achieving The Correct Bevel Angle
- BCB Crusader II Mug Review
- LNT vs Bushcraft, Overcoming Foraging Fears, Stoves, DIY Sleeping Bags | #AskPaulKirtley 32
- Survival Skills: How To Prioritise In A Survival Situation
- Can I Take My Knife, Axe Or Saw On A Plane?
- Traditional Crafts Integration, Cheaper Full-Tang Knives, Places To Camp | #AskPaulKirtley 43
- Bog Myrtle As A Natural Insect Repellent | Bushcraft Quick Tips
- Capsized On England's Largest Lake - Can They Self Rescue?
- Can You Tell If Water Is Safe To Drink Just By Looking At It?
- How To Use A Swim Line To Self Rescue A Canoe
- What Makes A Bushcraft Knife A Bushcraft Knife, Leather Belt Kits | #AskPaulKirtley 45
- The Difference Between Foraging & Living Off The Land | Bushcraft Show 2013
- Knife Grinds For Bushcraft, Pooping In The Woods & Bushcraft Kit Obsession | #AskPaulKirtley Ep. 30
- What To Pack For A Day Hike In The Woods
- Accelerate Your Bushcraft Learning | Bushcraft Show 2017 Main Stage Presentation
- My Views On Survival Shows and Is Bow Drill Realistic? | #AskPaulKirtley Ep. 26
- Winter Woodland Wild Camping Tips
- The River Crake Canoe Caper
- Long Log Fire Lays, Sparks From Axes, Old Man's Beard, Outdoor Fitness | #AskPaulKirtley 33
- AskPaulKirtley Ep 29 - Ray Goodwin Special
- Water Indicating Trees, Full Campfire Burnout, Ideal Winter Hot Tents | #AskPaulKirtley 58
- Weird Encounters At Night, Drugs Tests, Predators and Wild Edibles | #AskPaulKirtley Episode 42
- Live Bushcraft and Survival Questions | #AskPaulKirtley Ep. 23
- How To Strike A Traditional Flint And Steel
- Foraging Calories, Expediton Menus, Selecting Trip Companions, Hike Hydration | #AskPaulKirtley 44
- #AskPaulKirtley Episode 6 - Bushcraft Aspirations, Bloodvein, Weather Forecasting, Wild Camping...
- Winter Bushcraft, Survival and Camping Questions | #AskPaulKirtley 41
- Lightening The Load Part 1 - Sleep Systems
- Tarps With Canoes, Earning From Bushcraft Content, Dealing With Frowns | #AskPaulKirtley 51
- Reshaping Knife With Secondary Bevel, Knots For Attaching Guylines To Tarps | #AskPaulKirtley 52
- Outdoor Career Advice, Tarp or Tent, Martial Arts & Bushcraft, Birch Harvesting | #AskPaulKirtley 37
- This Is Canoeing DVD Giveaway
- Bushcraft: How To Tie An Adjustable Guyline Hitch
- How To Create Really Big Sparks With A Swedish Firesteel
- Bow Drill Fire Making - What Is The Point?
- #AskPaulKirtley Ep. 15 - Squeaky Bow-Drills, Firebowls, Snakes & Bugs Under Tarps
- ONE Thing For Survival, Learning Fungi, Oak Bark Tinder, Knots & Lashings | #AskPaulKirtley 40
- Bushcraft - Essential Winter Fire Lighting Techniques
- #AskPaulKirtley Ep. 11 - Multi-tools vs Knives, Bug Nets, Kit Storage & Bushcraft Freedom Worldwide
- After The Devastation - Canoeing The River Greta
- #AskPaulKirtley Ep. 17 - Bivvy Condensation, Tyvek, Wool Blankets and Wilderness Licences
- Sparks With A Stainless Steel Pocket Knife And Ferro Rod
- Paul Kirtley YouTube Channel Update May 2015
- How To Wear A Bushcraft Knife When Carrying A Rucksack
- How To Light Birch Bark With A Spark
- Bushcraft Quick Tips - How To Tell A Sedge From A Grass (And Why)
- Halloween Pumpkin Carnage
- #AskPaulKirtley 12 - Starting Bushcraft Schools, Storing Knives, Burning Trash & Cooking Starches
- #AskPaulKirtley Episode 3 - Kids & Bushcraft, Ticks, Tinders, Friction Fire & Seeing Wildlife
- Bushcraft Take-Aways From The Manitoba Museum
- Tracking & Trapping, Birch Bark & Firewood, Breaking Knives | #AskPaulKirtley Ep. 24
- Winter Bushcraft Skills: Tree Felling For Firewood
- Bushcraft Quick Tips - Remember The Threads
- Widowmakers, Umbrellas, Resinous Bow-Drill Wood, Shorts | #AskPaulKirtley 55
- Bushcraft Mythbusters: Bracken Beds
- A Day On The Dee: Weirs, Waves And World Heritage
- Bushcraft Quick Tips - How To Cut A Sapling Efficiently With Your Knife
- Finding Flint, Managing Fires Overnight and The Best Matches | #AskPaulKirtley Ep. 28
- Electrical Storms, Trekking Poles For Tarps, When To Stop Bow Drilling | #AskPaulKirtley Ep. 31
- Tarps Are OK Until It Rains
- Bushcraft Clothes: Favourite Thermal Layer & Shell Combos For The Woods
- Top Bushcraft Trees, Light Saws, Axe & Knife Home Maintenance | #AskPaulKirtley 35
- Bushcraft: How To Tie An Evenk Hitch
- #AskPaulKirtley Ep 10 - Knife Lanyards, Hammocks vs Tarps, Tinder Boxes, NGB Awards For Bushcraft
- Canoeing The Bloodvein River (Short)
- How To Use A StrikeFire Fire Starter
- How To Stay Dry Under A Tarp
- #AskPaulKirtley Ep. 14 - Toxic Firewood, Lost In The Woods, Bushcrafter Knowledge & Rewilding
- Optimising Tinder Bundle Airflow, Finding Wildlife, Keeping Gear Dry | #AskPaulKirtley 47
- #AskPaulKirtley Episode 1 - Bushcraft Knives, Books & The Kitchen Sink
- Bushcraft Philosophy, Smoky Firewood, Iodine, Leatherworking | #AskPaulkirtley 54
- Survival: What To Do If You Get Lost Outdoors
- How Do I Know When I Have Enough Knowledge To Visit Wilderness On My Own?
- Relevant First Aid, Calculating Hiking Timings, Eating Plantain Seeds | #AskPaulKirtley 59
- Technology In The Way? Camp Set-Up Times, Rust Prevention, Slugs | #AskPaulKirtley 60
- Birch Polypore Strops, Trees & Plants To Learn, Axe Repairs | #AskPaulKirtley 61
- Five Mile Rapids, French River - High Water In Late Summer
- Campfires On Rock, Group Morale, Dangers of Woodsmoke | #AskPauKirtley 62
- Fire Saw, Wilderness Water, Tripod Withies, Personal Daily Camp Routines | #AskPaulKirtley 63
- Best Bushcraft Moments Of 2017, Match Storage, Kids & Canoe Camping | #AskPaulKirtley 64
- Tips For Fires Under Tarps, Cat-Tail Fibre Extraction, Bushcraft On TV | #AskPaulKirtley 65
- How To Get To The Northern Forest, Multi-Purpose Bivvies, Loneliness, Cooksets | #AskPaulKirtley 66
- The Best Long-Log Fire
- Military Surlplus vs Non-Surplus; Mediterranean Bushcraft | #AskPaulKirtley 69
- Roycroft Pack Frames, Sharpening & Oiling Bushcraft Knives | #AskPaulKirtley 71
- Too Many Clothes. Desert Fires. Bushcraft for Young People. Bush Music | #AskPaulKirtley 67
- Belt Attachments For Bushcraft & Outdoor Life
- Eureka Moments With The Hazda. Striking Matches With Your Teeth. | #AskPaulKirtley 68
- How To Tie A Double Fisherman's Knot | Bushcraft & Outdoor Knots
- Real Survival With No Food; Banking Fires; CAT Tourniquets | #AskPaulKirtley 70
- Olight M2T Warrior Review - Initial Thoughts
- Inner Bark Tinder Bundles; Smokeless Fires; First Aid For Young People | AskPaulKirtley 76
- Testing If Water Filters Work; When To Start Teaching Bushcraft | #AskPaulKirtley 75
- Bushcraft Show 2018 Axe Demo | Paul Kirtley | Frontier Bushcraft
- Deer Carcass Inpection; Identifying Useful Trees; Made Items | #AskPaulKirtley 72
- How To Tie A Double Sheet Bend | Bushcraft & Outdoor Knots
- Mora Garberg Review: 18 Months of Professional Use
- Moving From Survival Training To Broader Bushcraft | #AskPaulKirtley 77
- Best Woods For Featherticks; Remedying Chipped Axes | #AskPaulKirtley 74
- Fire Hardening, Froth in Filtered Water, Tarps In Rain (Again) | #AskPaulKirtley 73
- Tarp Guyline Angle Hack
- Bushcraft Show 2018 Main Stage Presentation
- Campfire Safety Risks; Boot Storage When Bivvying | #AskPaulKirtley 78
- An Announcement, A Small Rant & Some Answers | #AskPaulKirtley 79